Most Games
- Season: 26
- Ken Perry, Steve Sanders, Randy “Moose” Taylor (1978-79)
- Kent Ayer, Eric Bruggenschmidt, Josh Garrett, Chris Holstein, Travis Smith (1992-93)
- Eric Gardner, Josh Garrett, Brian Guth, Chris Holstein, Emi Morales, Travis Smith, Rob Zaricki (1993-94)
- Matthew Embry, Kobe Stephens, Trey Toler (2015-16)
- Career: 100
- Josh Garrett (1992-93 through 1995-96)
Most Points
- One Quarter: 19
- Parrish Casebier vs Gibson Southern (W, 83-57), 12/16/1989
- One Half: 30
- Parrish Casebier vs North Posey (W, 82-62), 12/2/1989
- Game: 49
- Parrish Casebier vs North Posey (W, 82-62), 12/2/1989
- Parrish Casebier vs Gibson Southern (W, 83-57), 12/16/1989
- Season: 721
- Parrish Casebier (1989-90)
- Career: 1,929
- Kent Ayer (1991-92 through 1994-95)
Highest Scoring Average
- Season: 32.2
- Parrish Casebier (1989-90)
- Career: 22.4
- Parrish Casebier (1986-87 through 1989-90)
Most Field Goals Made
- Game: 19
- Parrish Casebier, at Southridge (W, 81-46), 2/17/1989
- Season: 265
- Parrish Casebier (1989-90)
- Career: 710
- Parrish Casebier (1986-87 through 1989-90)
Highest Field Goal Percentage
- Game: 1.000 (8-8)
- Mike Erwin, vs Huntingburg (W, 85-48), 2/19/1971
- Season: .645
- Andy Harpenau (2002-03)
- Career:
Most 3-Point Field Goals Made
- Game: 10
- Kent Ayer, vs. Mt Vernon (W, 94-48), 12/16/1994
- Season: 63
- Kyle Magill (2001-02), Shawn Kuester (2005-06)
- Career: 196
- Kyle Magill (1999-00 through 2002-03)
Highest 3-Point Field Goal Percentage
- Game: 1.00 (5-5)
- Michael Donoho, vs Crawford County (W, 75-62), 12/28/2019
- Season: .483 (28-58)
- Dirk Lehr (1987-88)
- Career:
Most Free Throws Made
- Game: 20 (out of 22)
- Michael Donoho, vs Crawford County (W, 75-62), 12/28/2019
- Season: 194 (out of 270)
- Parrish Casebier (1986-87 through 1989-90)
- Career: 521 (out of 649)
- Kent Ayer (1991-92 through 1994-95)
Most Free Throws Attempted
- Game: 26
- Mike Partridge (made 18), vs Owensville (W, 78-52), 2/9/1968
- Season: 270
- Parrish Casebier (made 194) (1986-87 through 1989-90)
- Career: 649
- Kent Ayer (made 521) (1991-92 through 1994-95)
Highest Free Throw Percentage
- Game: 1.00 (15-15)
- Mike Partridge, vs Owensville (W, 78-52), 2/9/1968
- Season: .898 (123-137)
- Keith Haaff (2006-07)
- Career: .868 (376-433)
- Jesse Howell (2001-02 through 2004-05)
Most Rebounds
- Game: 33
- Mike Erwin, vs Ferdinand (W, 78-68), 1/13/1970
- Season: 468
- Mike Erwin (1969-70)
- Career: 1,358
- Mike Erwin (1968-69 through 1971-72)
Highest Rebound Average
- Season: 21.3
- Mike Erwin (1969-70)
- Career: 16.6
- Mike Erwin (1968-69 through 1971-72)
Most Assists
- Game: 12
- Mike Guth, at Southridge (W, 81-46), 12/17/1989
- Season: 123
- Mike Guth (1990-91)
- Career: 324
- Josh Garrett (1992-93 through 1995-96)
Most Blocked Shots
- Game: 13
- Mike Erwin, vs North Posey (W, 78-52), 12/3/1971
- Ken Perry, at Tell City (W, 43-41), 1/15/1980
- Season:
- Mike Erwin
- Career:
- Mike Erwin
Most Steals
- Game:
- Season: 62
- Randy “Moose” Taylor (1978-79)
- Career:
Consecutive Free Throws Made
- 27
- Adam Bruggenschmidt (1991-92)
- Kent Ayer (1994-95)